Paul Lentz, Author
  • Blog
  • Authors of Note
  • Contact

Thanksgiving—For What?

11/24/2016

 
Today is Thanksgiving, the day we give thanks for… what? For the day that settlers from England gave smallpox to the aboriginal inhabitants of this continent?
 
Are we thankful that we are the greatest nation on Earth, before falling asleep in front of a 54-inch HDTV made in China or Korea, and showing a gladiatorial game?
 
As an aside, the flyers in my mailbox this week are pushing both snack food and anti-acids. Am I the only one who sees the irony?
 
What do we have to be thankful for?
 
First, the USA is still the best place on Earth to live. Except perhaps Canada, which has universal health coverage of the sort that the Republican Party and Trump would like to destroy.
 
Okay, it’s a lot colder in Canada and their definition of “football” is, well, not quite what we think. I’m reminded of the apothegm: “Soccer is football for gentlemen; football is football for idiots.”
 
Don’t get me wrong. I am a patriot. I’m pretty sure that the United States is the best place on Earth to live. On the other hand I understand the fallacy in the notion of, “My country, right or wrong.”
 
Make no mistake. We’ve been wrong. We adopted a constitution that enshrined slavery. Then we fought a war over this flaw in our constitution and then amended the constitution to prohibit involuntary servitude except for criminals. Then, we took advantage of that loophole and ran the steel mills of Birmingham and cotton plantations of Mississippi with what amounted to slave labor.
 
Our Supreme Court once ruled that women, by their very temperament, could not be lawyers. The Jewish bible, whose influence is unfortunately revered by today’s fundamentalists, sets the value of a woman at 60% that of a man—and women’s salaries still reflect that ancient, masochistic value. We elected to be our president a man whose statements clearly show he does not respect women.
 
We passed a constitutional amendment that prohibits restrictions on voting based on race. When white supremacists implemented poll taxes to stop Negroes from voting, we passed another amendment to stop that.
 
However, when white supremacists and Republicans make it difficult for persons of color to vote by restricting early voting to work days and by limiting places for early voting, no one spoke out, and the Supreme Court failed to stop this. This, by the way, is the situation today. As of 2016.
 
It’s obvious that we have not gone very far past the prejudices of the late 19th century. It’s obvious that institutional and individual racist views persist.
 
I see this when a local elected official denigrates apartment complexes. His argument that apartments “decay faster” than individual homes is specious. His real concern is that “apartments” means “Section 8” which means “poor, black.” Can you say, “dog-whistle?” *
 
By the way, the expression, “My country, right or wrong,” is often attributed to Carl Schurz, in 1812. But what he said was, “My country, right or wrong; if right, to be kept right; and if wrong, to be set right.”
 
The outcome of the recent presidential election and the ongoing transition show me that as a nation we seem to have lost sight of the second part of Schurz’s toast.
 
 
Notes and references.
I don’t want to say, “Indians,” since that perpetuates an error on the part of Columbus and others. I don’t want to say “Native Americans,” because technically, having been born in this country I am a native American, but not an enrolled member of any nation or tribe. I’ll use the more technical term, “aboriginal,” meaning “before the origin”—of recorded history, at least.
 
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=dog%20whistle
 
 * Dog whistle is a strategy of communication that sends a message that the general population will take a certain meaning from, but a certain group that is "in the know" will take away the secret, intended message. Often involves code words.
 
For example: Republicans say they want to make civil rights for gays a state issue, which is really just a dog whistle strategy for saying that they will refuse to grant equal rights on a federal level.
 
The series, “It’s All About the Children—Climate” will resume no later than Saturday with “Sunspots.”

Comments are closed.

    Author

    Registered Curmudgeon, scientist, skeptic, humanist, and writer.

    Archives

    April 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016

    Categories

    All
    1984
    2016 Election
    2016 Presidential Campaign
    9th Circuit
    Afghanistan
    Aleppo
    Alien And Sedition Acts
    Alternative Facts
    Alt-right
    Antifa
    Anti-Semitism
    Arms Trade
    Baasad
    Barrel Bombs
    Bigotry
    Biodiversity
    Black Baby Deaths
    Black Lives Matter
    Boko Haram
    Border Wall
    Carrying Capacity
    CFCs HFCs HFOs
    Charlotte Riots
    Clean Coal
    Climate Change
    Climate Denier
    Cognitive Dissonance
    Collapse Of Civilization
    Crumbling Infrastructure
    Daesh (ISIS/ISIL)
    Dark Mountain Manifesto
    Dean Spicer
    Democratic Party Platform
    Donald Trump
    Doublethink
    Down Syndrome
    Duerte
    Dystopia
    Economics 101
    Election 2016
    Equifax
    Evolution
    F-35
    Fake News
    Fallacies Of Logic
    Federal Trade Commission
    First Amendment
    Flag Burning
    Football CTE
    Foxprop
    Fundamentalism
    Gary Johnson
    GBU-43
    Georgia Gasoline Crisis
    Georgia Gasoline Pipeline
    GHG
    Global Climate Change
    Global Warming
    God
    Government Bureaucracy
    Government Shutdown
    Graven Images
    Greenhouse Gas
    Greenhouse Gasses
    Group Think
    Gunboat Diplomacy
    Hacking
    HADO Water Crystals
    "Happy Holidays"
    Harvey
    Hillary Clinton
    Homophobia
    Hurricane Harvey
    Hurricane Irma
    Hurricane Katrina
    Incest
    Income Inequality
    Infant Mortality
    Integration
    Internet Bullying
    Internet Gatekeepers
    Internet Trolls
    Internment Camps
    IPCC
    Irma
    Iron Dome
    ISIS
    Israel
    Jared Diamond
    Kaka
    Katrina
    Kigali Amendment
    Law Of Unintended Consequences
    Leni Riefenstahl
    Libertarian
    Logical Fallacies
    Loose Cannon
    Lynching
    Malthus
    Malthusian Solution
    Marine Corps
    Marriage
    Masura Emoto
    Methane Emission Rule
    Milancovic Cycles
    Misogyny
    MOAB
    Montreal Protocol
    Mt. Pinatubo
    Mt. Tambora
    Muslim Ban
    Nazis
    Neo-Nazi
    Newnan
    Newspeech
    News Sources
    Nuclear Arsenal
    Nuclear Warfare
    Obama
    Opiate Of The Massives
    Organized Religion
    Orwell 1984
    Out Of Africa
    Ozone Hole
    Perceptual Filters
    Peter Abelard
    Pity The Children
    Politcal Correctness
    Polygamy
    Prisons Of Our Minds
    Propaganda
    Proxy War
    Putin
    Qatar
    Rally In Newnan
    Recycling
    Red Herrings
    Republican Convention
    Republican Party Platform
    Righteous Right
    Robert Mercer
    Russian Cyber Attacks
    Russian Hacking
    Russian Internet Trolls
    Scorched-earth
    SCOTUS
    Scotus Nominee
    Sexual Dimorphism
    Social Media
    Solar Eclipse
    Stream Protection Rule
    Sunspots
    Syria
    Tardisboy
    Teflon Don
    Ten Commandments
    Terrorism
    The Coming Collapse
    Third Presidential Debate
    Trigger Warnings
    Trump
    Trump 2020
    Trump Ad Hominem
    Trump And Climate
    Trump And EPA
    Trump Cabinet
    Trump China Policy
    Trump Executive Order
    Trump Legacy
    Trump Lies
    Trump's Chumps
    USMC
    War On Drugs
    War On Poverty
    Wealth Inequality
    Whale Song
    White Supremacists
    White Supremacy
    WikiLeaks
    Willing Suspension Of Disbelief
    Writing Fiction
    Young Earth Creationism
    Zero Tolerance
    Zero-Tolerance
    Zika Virus

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Blog
  • Authors of Note
  • Contact
✕